109 – The OTHER Reason Why We Overeat and Binge with Isabel Foxen Duke

by | Dec 17, 2017

reason why we overeat

Listen to the episode 

Subscribe:iTunes | RSS | Sticher

In this episode I discuss  

We shouldn’t avoid emotional eating because when we turn emotional eating into something to avoid as much as dieting, we fall in the trap of diet mentality and all its negative side effects such as overeating and binging. Isabel Foxen Duke is a brilliant leader in the Health At Every Size movement and this interview will rock your world! Must listen!

The Reason Why We Overeat and Binge

Perfectionistic expectation will absolutely lead to rebellion. When applied to food, it will lead to binging and overeating in the same way that perfectionistic expectation to work will lead to burnout. We cannot uphold those expectations. It’s impossible to keep it up all the time, so we end up crashing. We crash in proportion to how rigid we were trying to hold on. And it’s important to understand this concept if we really want to understand the reason why we overeat and binge. 

The more you attempt dieting, the less you are likely to stick to one.  Historically, we’ve always been emotional eaters. When we look at the evolution of the human being, we’ve eaten emotionally, socially, so we cannot cut it off. So, when we try to cease emotional eating from existing, we end up being on the wagon, off the wagon, on the wagon a.k.a. yo-yo dieting. The problem with most people is that they haven’t addressed the diet mentality that’s why they fail to understand the reason why we overeat and binge. 

This is the reason why I developed a program to help women like you and me to put an end to emotional eating called Conquer Emotional Eating. This online program is designed to provide you the education to understand and transform why you emotionally eat and to put a stop to being the victim of your food urges.

Looking from the Inside

Diet mentality goes more than just a relationship with food. It’s the way we approach life in general. We often look at our happiness through a solution that is external to us instead of looking at finding happiness, joy, and fulfillment from inside. In the same way we relate to diet, we think that controlling our external environment a.k.a. our food will lead us to happiness instead of looking from the inside. If you think that you are going to find happiness by eating a certain way, not only you aren’t going to find it there, but you are probably going to fail at it, to begin with. What’s interesting is that, when we put perfection to our food, chances are we also apply perfection in many other aspects of our lives because we lack trust in ourselves.

What does your body want you to eat? That only solves half the problem. The other half of the problem is how we think. It’s how we talk to ourselves. Are we living in diet mentality? Are we approaching food like is a thing that we should be careful around?

Body Image Issues

I’m overweight, but I’m healthier than 90% of the people out there. The reason is because it has nothing to do with weight. Weight is not a causal effect of health, just a by-product. This desire for weight loss beyond health is what we call the body image issue.

Ninety-nine percent of food issue boils down to body image issues. Majority of disordered eating behaviors start
with “I don’t think my body is enough and I feel like I should try and change it by restricting my food.” If you never had the thought, “I wish I was thinner,” you would never have gone on a diet, you would never deal with this binge eating, emotional eating problems. Emotional eating is heavily correlated with dieting. The more you diet, the more you restrict, the more you’re going to turn to food for comfort and that clearly gives us a better perspective on the reason why we overeat and binge. 

Health at Every Size

“It’s a lot easier to stop obsessing about food when we feel good about ourselves.”

There is a whole movement that is trying to demonstrate that beautiful people come in different shapes and sizes. There’s a ton of evidence that if you are exposing yourself to body diversity visually on a regular basis, it will actually start to change your brain. It will change the way it looks at bodies including your body, thereby, transforming how you tackle body image.

Ready to deep dive into the process to transform your relationship to food and body so you can take control of your life and live confidently right now? Join the Going Beyond the Food Academy today.

Links mentioned in this episode:  

Stop Fighting Food : a free 3 part video series from Isabel Foxen Duke: http://stopfightingfood.com/ 

Health at Every Size bookhttp://amzn.to/2kyNVlB 

Going Beyond the Food Academy: https://www.stephaniedodier.com/academy/    

Support me by leaving a review about this episode: http://bit.ly/2gilTsw


How you can reach Stephanie: 


FB: https://www.facebook.com/StephanieDodiernutrition  

Instagram: https://instagram.com/stephdodier/  


Email: [email protected]  


Got a question for Stephanie you’d like her to answer, or just want to join our community of women?

Our free and private community:




Going Beyond the Food Academy

End Food Obsession


***For your information – some links above may be my affiliate links, which means I get a small commission if you click on it and make a purchase. Doing so will NOT entail any additional cost to you, but will help me tremendously. Your support is SO greatly appreciated, so thank you in advance if you choose to do so***

Podcast Stephanie Dodier


I’m Stephanie Dodier – Non-Diet Nutritionist and Coach. I help women fight diet culture by reshaping their mind not their body. I have been hosting a million downloads podcast- It’s Beyond The Food for over 8 years and created the Going Beyond The Food Method™️, which was born from my own journey with a 25 years dieting career  and has since grown into a global movement.

Get started with our free eating, body image and mindset free assessments.

Get Your Free Non-Diet Assessments

Search Podcast Episodes

Success Stories

Julie Mann

The Going Beyond the Food Method is an amazingly comprehensive program…

Peg Seitz Wedig

Stephanie’s program was life-changing for me…

Deanna McKay

Stephanie”s program tools work…

Jacquie Sands

Working with Stephanie has been a body, mind and…


Stephanie’s program was an eye-opening and life-changing….

Subscribe to Our Podcast


Questions about body image, food, mindset, motivation, goal setting…


You have Successfully Subscribed!



Watch the recording of the Rebellious Eating Solution Masterclass 

You have Successfully Subscribed!



3-Part Masterclass Series 

You have Successfully Subscribed!

diet quiz



Take the Quiz and find out. 

You have Successfully Subscribed!



Register for the Rebellious Eating Solution Masterclass 

You have Successfully Subscribed!